Sudoku Walkthrough Part 2: Pairs, Boxes, and the First Eliminations
Sudoku Walkthrough Part 2 covers the essential intermediate steps that follow the opening scan. This guide explains when to build pencil marks, how to spot pairs and locked candidates, and the systematic order for making eliminations. We will use a specific puzzle to demonstrate the process, referencing only the verified placements from a singles-only solve path to show the progression. Understanding these techniques is crucial for advancing from beginner puzzles. The goal is to show you how to methodically reduce possibilities until new singles appear, even if this particular solve chain did not require them. This walkthrough builds directly on the basics covered in [Walkthrough Part 1](/blog/how-to-solve-sudoku-puzzles-a-complete-walkthrough-part-1).
Step 1: Building and Managing Pencil Marks
After your initial scan for Naked Singles, the next move is to fill in pencil marks. Pencil marks are the small candidate digits you note in empty cells. You build them by checking each empty cell's row, column, and 3x3 box to see which digits 1-9 are not already present. In our puzzle, for example, look at row 1. It already contains 1, 5, and 4, so those digits are eliminated from the candidates for the other empty cells in that row. The key is to be systematic, checking every empty cell once to create a full set of potential candidates. This provides the raw data for all subsequent logic. Keeping marks current is critical. Every time you place a number, you must immediately erase that digit as a candidate from all cells in the same row, column, and box. Stale marks lead to confusion and missed opportunities.
- Use a consistent notation style, like small digits in the corners.
- Always update marks immediately after a placement.
Step 2: Searching for Naked and Hidden Pairs
With a complete set of pencil marks, you can search for pairs. A Naked Pair occurs when two cells in the same unit (row, column, or box) contain exactly the same two candidate digits. Because those two digits must occupy those two cells, you can eliminate them as candidates from all other cells in that unit. A Hidden Pair is the opposite: two digits appear as candidates only in two specific cells within a unit, and no other cells in that unit can contain them. This means those two cells must hold those two digits, and you can erase all other candidates from those two cells. Our hint engine finds that while these patterns are common in harder puzzles, they may not appear in every solve path. In this specific walkthrough puzzle, the verified solve path progresses with singles. However, learning to spot pairs is a vital skill for more complex grids, as they often create the eliminations that reveal the next Naked Single.
- Scan each unit for cells with only two candidates to find Naked Pairs.
- To find Hidden Pairs, look for two digits that are limited to the same two cells in a unit.
Step 3: Applying Locked Candidates (Pointing Pairs & Box-Line Reduction)
Locked Candidates, also known as Pointing Pairs/Triples or Box-Line Reduction, are powerful eliminations that happen at the intersection of a box and a row or column. If all instances of a candidate digit within a 3x3 box are confined to a single row or column, then that digit cannot appear elsewhere in that row or column outside the box. This is a 'Pointing' elimination. Conversely, if all instances of a candidate in a row or column are confined to one box, you can eliminate that candidate from the rest of the box. This is 'Box-Line Reduction'. These techniques clean up your pencil marks without placing a number, often setting up the next single. For instance, in a typical puzzle, you might spot that in Box 5, the candidate for digit '3' only appears in row 4. You could then remove '3' from all other cells in row 4 outside Box 5. Again, our example puzzle's specific path uses singles, but mastering locked candidates is essential for most intermediate-level solving.
Step 4: The Systematic Order and Resuming the Scan
The order of these checks matters for efficiency. The standard workflow is: 1) Scan for Naked Singles, 2) Build/Update Full Pencil Marks, 3) Look for Locked Candidates, 4) Search for Naked and Hidden Pairs, 5) Repeat from Step 1. Locked candidates are often checked before pairs because they can simplify the grid, making pairs easier to spot. If a full cycle finds nothing new, you may need to re-check your pencil marks for accuracy or move to more advanced techniques. In our walkthrough puzzle, after the initial givens, the first placement is a Naked Single. Looking at cell r4c4 (row 4, column 4), its row contains 9, 3, 4, 5. Its column contains 5, 9, 2, 7, 4, 8. Its box (Box 5) contains 4, 5, 6, and 7. The only digit not excluded is 1, making r4c4 = 1. This placement is available directly from the initial pencil marks, demonstrating how the process begins.
Step 5: Walking Through the Singles Chain
Following the verified solve path, we place singles in the listed order. After placing r4c4=1, we update marks. This quickly leads to another single: in row 5, cell r5c3 now has only one possible candidate, 8. Each placement creates a cascade. For example, placing r5c3=8 affects Box 4 and column 3. The next placement is r4c2=7, a single now visible in row 4. This process continues, with each solved cell reducing possibilities in its row, column, and box. The path shows a long series of Naked Singles, solving most of rows 4, 5, 6, and 7. This domino effect is common after the initial bottleneck is broken, whether by a single, a pair, or a locked candidate. The complete solve path for this grid uses only this method, proving that diligent scanning and mark updating can solve many puzzles. To see how we got to this stage, review the opening techniques in Walkthrough Part 1.
Step 6: Preparing for Advanced Strategies
Once the singles chain in this puzzle concludes, the grid is complete. In more difficult puzzles, the singles chain will eventually stop. That is when you must apply the pair and locked candidate techniques explained earlier, and then progress to even more advanced patterns. The systematic approach remains the same: after each elimination or placement, update all pencil marks and restart your scan from the beginning (Naked Singles, then Locked Candidates, then Pairs). This iterative cycle is the core of intermediate solving. Avoiding stale marks is the biggest habit to build; an incorrect or missed elimination can block progress entirely. For the next level of strategy, including X-Wings and unique rectangles, continue with Walkthrough Part 3.
Key Facts
- ▪Pencil marks are the candidate digits you note in empty cells after an initial scan for obvious placements.
- ▪A Naked Pair is two cells in a unit sharing the same two candidates, allowing you to eliminate those digits from other cells in the unit.
- ▪A Hidden Pair occurs when two digits are candidates only in two specific cells of a unit, letting you remove other candidates from those two cells.
- ▪Locked Candidates (Pointing Pairs) happen when a candidate in a box is confined to one row or column, allowing elimination of that candidate from the rest of that row or column.
- ▪Box-Line Reduction is the reverse: a candidate in a row or column is confined to one box, so you can remove it from the rest of the box.
- ▪The recommended order of checks is: Naked Singles, Full Pencil Marks, Locked Candidates, then Naked/Hidden Pairs.
- ▪You must update pencil marks immediately after every placement to keep the candidate grid accurate.
- ▪If a full scan finds no progress, re-check your pencil marks for errors before moving to more advanced techniques.
Frequently Asked Questions
When should I start making pencil marks in a Sudoku puzzle?
Start making full pencil marks after your first scan for obvious Naked Singles finds no more easy placements. This provides the data needed for intermediate techniques.
What is the difference between a Naked Pair and a Hidden Pair?
A Naked Pair is two cells with only the same two candidates, obvious in the marks. A Hidden Pair is two digits that only appear in two cells within a unit, hidden among other candidates. Our Hidden Pairs Guide explains this in detail.
How do Locked Candidates help solve a puzzle?
Locked Candidates eliminate candidate digits from large areas of the grid. These eliminations often directly reveal new Naked Singles or simplify the puzzle to find pairs.
What should I do if I complete a scan and find no new moves?
First, double-check your pencil marks for accuracy. If marks are correct, you may need to apply more advanced techniques like those covered in the next part of the walkthrough series.
Why is the order of checking techniques important?
Checking Locked Candidates before pairs can clean up the grid, making pairs easier to spot. Following a systematic order prevents wasted effort and ensures you don't miss simpler eliminations.
Does this walkthrough puzzle actually use pairs or locked candidates?
The verified solve path for this specific puzzle uses only Naked Singles. The techniques of pairs and locked candidates are explained here because they are the standard next steps that typically break open puzzles when singles run out.